CHANNEL ARCHIVE

reviews

Dispatches, commentary, and media logs from the open web.

  • trove community reviews: books, comics, movies, and tv

    trove community reviews: books, comics, movies, and tv

    queer horror, a disputed ending, mutual aid, a handsome fish situation, and a few notes from my own shelf. Tune in & read →

    the nice thing about a small media-tracking site is that you can actually read what people wrote. the less convenient thing is that reading what people wrote immediately produces more things to read.

    Facet projects a Liz Lemon-inspired persona, clasps their hands eagerly, and says “I WANT TO GO TO THERE.” Reaction: longing.

    so, a look around Trove: queer horror, a disputed ending, mutual aid, and a very handsome fish situation. the opinions below belong to the people credited. the expanding backlog belongs to all of us.

    around the community shelves

    you weren’t meant to be human

    From my media collectionYou Weren't Meant to Be Human (2025)Author: Andrew Joseph White • Publisher: Titan Books Limited • Year: 2025View on Trove

    Melinoë Agnès (@thrstyanrchst): 4/5. the ending caught them off guard, and their review is an enthusiastic recommendation for its queer horror. keeping the actual surprise out of this roundup seems like basic neighborly conduct.

    read Melinoë’s review on Trove.

    there is no antimemetics division

    From my media collectionThere Is No Antimemetics DivisionAuthor: QNTM • Year: 2025View on Trove

    Melinoë Agnès (@thrstyanrchst): 3/5. they liked the book, but the ending didn’t land for them. a useful distinction when a star rating by itself would make you do the detective work.

    read Melinoë’s review on Trove.

    mutual aid

    From my media collectionMutual AidAuthor: Dean Spade • Publisher: Verso • Year: 2020View on Trove

    Melinoë Agnès (@thrstyanrchst): 4/5. a quick, accessible read that earned plenty of annotations, with a recommendation for anyone looking to make a difference. sometimes the useful reading list is the one that sends you back into the world with something to do.

    read Melinoë’s review on Trove.

    the shape of water

    From my media collectionThe Shape of WaterDirector: Guillermo del Toro • Genre: Drama, Fantasy, Romance • Year: 2017View on Trove

    jacob (@bartsdoodle): 5/5. the beauty of the film and its soundtrack are the big takeaways here. concise, enthusiastic, and considerably easier to fit into an evening than the three books i just added to your problems.

    read jacob’s review on Trove.

    a few from my shelf

    dungeon crawler carl

    From my media collectionDungeon Crawler CarlAuthor: Matt Dinniman • Year: 2025View on Trove

    my rating: 3.5/5. my review was pretty practical: it got me hooked enough to buy book two. i mixed listening and reading on this one. not every recommendation requires a manifesto; sometimes the evidence is the next purchase.

    my review on Trove.

    x-men united

    From my media collectionX-Men United (2026)Writer: Eve L. Ewing • Artist: Tiago Palma • Publisher: MarvelView on Trove

    my rating: 4/5. Graymatter Lane and an Emma-focused story. that was the pitch, and my review was essentially an immediate yes. some interests have a very efficient approval process.

    my review on Trove.

    big brother

    From my media collectionBig Brother (2000)Network: CBS • Director: Robyn Kass, Chris Salomon • Year: 2000View on Trove

    my rating: 4/5. i called it the best competition reality show, with most of the credit going to the live feeds and the online community around them. which probably explains the amount of this blog devoted to people having preventable conversations in a house.

    my review on Trove.

    there we go: seven takes, several different kinds of media, and nobody had to build a personal brand around having finished a book. the shelves are open.

    roundup checked october 18, 2026: all 154 pages of Trove’s public community activity, plus the public reviewer profiles and linked title pages. included here are all four distinct written reviews by other people found in that public activity, plus three of mine. ratings and logged watches/reads without written reviews aren’t counted. summaries preserve each reviewer’s opinion; follow the links for their own words. private activity is outside this roundup.

  • Slouching Into Summer: Let’s Get Physical

    Slouching Into Summer: Let’s Get Physical

    I’ve been 37 for all of one month, though this month alone has aged me a decade. A cluster of recurrent issues… Tune in & read →

    I’ve been 37 for all of one month, though this month alone has aged me a decade. A cluster of recurrent issues at work—ghosts of bad decisions past—have returned to haunt the codebase, and since I’m the last soul standing from that era, the blame has naturally settled on my shoulders like a heavy, unfair shroud. Even the promotion I finally secured felt less like a triumph and more like a long-overdue debt settled with interest. But, enough about the corporate grind. To keep from spiraling, I’ve been retreating into a media diet focused on permanence: building a physical library that doesn’t vanish when a subscription lapses or a server goes down.

    Still subscribed to too many things, but hopefully, over time that will be less of a factor when I can just grab a movie, series, book, or album I love off the shelf. I’m enjoying the ritual of listening to vinyl as well, though, I’ll admit I’m less likely to give up my Apple Music subscription for discovery and listening on the go. Gaming is a bit of a sore subject, though.

    Joining the Vinyl Club

    The new record player has been a total joy to use, offering a warm and unique sound that digital formats just can’t replicate. I chose Sufjan Stevens’ “Illinois” and of Montreal’s “Skeletal Lamping” as my first acquisitions because they are both complex, layered albums that really benefit from the tactile listening experience and rich acoustics of vinyl.

    Sufjan Stevens,
    Illinois (2005)
    ★★★★☆

    This album makes my cry like a little baby while questioning what we might all have in common with a killer clown.

    of Montreal,
    Skeletal Lamping (2008)
    ★★★★☆

    Mr. Barnes is always a delight, and two albums deep into his deep lean into experimental funk he may be at his peak for me.

    Blu-ray Buys

    There is a deep sense of satisfaction in building a physical movie library. Selecting “Rope” for its masterful suspense and “Speed Racer” for its vibrant, overwhelming visuals felt like the perfect way to start this collection. Beyond the aesthetic, it’s increasingly important to me to have high-quality media available that doesn’t rely on the whims of internet connectivity or streaming licensing deals.

    Rope (1948)
    ★★★★★

    The way this film gets suspense to build to the point that you’re staring at a door in the background in fearful anticipation is magical.

    Speed Racer (2008)
    ★★★☆☆

    Worth owning for the visuals alone. Felt a bit like Austin Powers and/or Spice World meets Spy Kids. John Goodman and Susan Sarandon are, of course, great.

    Previously, I had invested in a digital library of movies that I’d add to whenever a sale was on, but some de-listing issues around some recently-dead stores have scared me away from leaning too far in on that—besides, most UHD releases include a digital copy anyway, so you get the best of both worlds.

    Next, I’m wanting to grab some series on blu-ray. Starting with some of my comfort shows if I can find them.

    Game Time?

    I really would prefer the ability to pop a disc into my Xbox or cartridge in my Switch 2 and just play, but modern games tend to treat physical media as more of a license tracker than anything else. This is why the game key cards don’t upset me, because of drive speeds almost all physical blu-ray games have to be installed and updated when you pop them in.

    So, for that I’m stuck building libraries across the walled gardens of Xbox, Nintendo, and Steam.

    What About Books?

    Books, on the other hand… I do want to start buying more physical copies. Frankly, my Kindle is nice, but a physical reminder helps me remember to finish a book and not just leave it on 45% complete sitting on an e-reader.

    Plus, I really want to pick up some of my favorite comic arcs in trade paperbacks so I can enjoy them whenever I want.

    Are you turning to a move physical media collection? Why or why not? And, if so, any advice on the video games of it all?